| Vote Voted! Voting | Bocci Trattoria & Pizzeria |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Colletta |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Enrigo Italian Bistro |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Fuhgeddaboudit Pizza |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Georgina's Restaurant |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Georginas |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Georginas Pizza |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Lugano Ristorante |
| Vote Voted! Voting | NY Pizza |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Paisans Italian Ristorante |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Piada Italian Street Food |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Piada Park West |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Pizzeria Faulisi |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Pro's Epicurean Market & Cafe |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Salvio's Pizzeria |
| Vote Voted! Voting | Sbarro |